317,793 people in the U.S. were arrested for cannabis possession in 2020 despite the growing legalization movement
Racial disparities have not changed over the past decade.
More than 300,000 people in the U.S. were arrested for cannabis possession in 2020, FBI records show. Meanwhile, the drug is being legally sold for a profit in 19 states.
That arrest number may sound high, but arrests have actually been going down each year since 2010 as more states legalize medical or recreational use of the drug. In 2019, for example, more than 500,000 cannabis possession arrests were reported, so the 2020 arrest numbers represent a single-year decline of 36 per cent.
In another sign of change, 2020 — the most recent year for which I consider the data reliable — was the first year that marijuana possession was not the most common cause for a drug arrest. Out of roughly 1.16 million drug arrests nationwide that year, 36 per cent were for possessing “other dangerous nonnarcotic drugs,” like cocaine and methamphetamine. Just over a quarter (27.5 per cent) of drug arrests were for possessing marijuana.
Despite these declines, racial disparities have not changed over the past decade. Black Americans accounted for about 38.8 per cent of marijuana possession arrests in 2020 despite representing just 13.6 per cent of the U.S. population and using cannabis at the same rate as white Americans, according to the National Survey on Drug Use and Health.
There are some caveats to consider when looking at 2020’s figures. Safety measures taken to limit the spread of COVID-19 — such as lockdowns, school closures and work-from-home mandates — resulted in fewer police-citizen contacts. The number of arrests for all drugs fell by 25 per cent compared with 2019, even though no other drugs were legalized that year. Still, arrests for cannabis declined at an even steeper rate.
New data reporting problems
Arrest data for 2021 is also problematic, but for different reasons.
Since the 1920s, the FBI has published crime statistics reported by local law enforcement agencies using the Summary Reporting System. This system always had limitations, notably counting only the most serious offence even when an arrest involves more than one charge.
To improve data collection, the FBI created the National Incident-Based Reporting System (NIBRS) in the 1980s. NIBRS collects much more detailed data.
The FBI has been trying to get law enforcement agencies to use NIBRS for years. Because the transition has been slow, the FBI has continued reporting crime data from the old system, too. Advocates, journalists and researchers like me relied on the old system because more police departments used it.
But on Jan. 1, 2021, the FBI started reporting only NIBRS-collected data. The agency insists this is not a serious issue, but only 52 per cent of agencies fully reported data last year. Two of the nation’s largest police departments, New York City and Los Angeles, did not report at all.
The low rate of agency participation suggests the FBI’s 2021 estimate of 170,856 cannabis possession arrests is a big undercount. For instance, in 2020, Florida reported 68,614 total drug abuse violations. In 2021, it reported 104 — even though there were no changes to drug laws in the state between those two years. Though growing pains are expected with a major data collection transition, as a researcher, I find it concerning to have such low confidence in the numbers meant to capture how laws are enforced.
Other measures to consider
Arrests for cannabis possession are dropping, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that the legal consequences of cannabis use are disappearing.
Courts often require people to go to treatment for marijuana use. The legal system has been the largest referrer to treatment for cannabis use since 1995.
In 2019, courts, probation and parole offices and diversion programs referred more than 100,000 individuals for cannabis use treatment. That accounts for roughly half (49.2 per cent) of all cannabis treatment admissions to publicly funded facilities. Roughly 30 per cent of these justice system referrals came from states in which marijuana use and sales are legal.
In research currently under peer review, my colleague Christopher Kulesza and I show that legalization is not associated with a significant decline in justice system referrals to cannabis treatment. Black and Latino adults and juveniles are more likely to be referred to treatment by the justice system than their white counterparts in both states where marijuana is legal and those where it isn’t.
Failure to comply with mandated treatment programs can result in the same negative consequences as an arrest and conviction, including detrimental effects on an individual’s health, education and employment prospects.
Our findings, along with other research, suggest that policymakers who want to reduce these consequences must find ways to root out arrest practices that unfairly target minority users and pay more attention to who is being referred for treatment.